sunnyFair, 61.0°

Question

Sound Off: I live on a private road (owned by a HOA). We have a problem with through traffic speeding and driving recklessly. Is there anything that we can do about this? The police will not come and enforce any kind of speed limit since it is not considered a city street, yet hundreds of cars per day that do not live there use it as if it were a city street. Things are getting really dangerous with cars traveling upwards of 45 mph on a residential drive with moderate foot traffic and no sidewalk. There have been a few accidents already and even more near misses. If the answer is to issue trespass warnings, who has the authority to do that?

Answer

David Woosley, the city’s traffic engineer, recommends that the homeowner discuss this issue with their homeowners association. The city will not install traffic-calming devices on private streets. The HOA could install speed humps in the area, which would be the most effective method for controlling speed at the areas. Trespassing warnings would need to be enforced and posted by the HOA.

Comments

Liberty275

Wow, first reply wins!

If I had a private road with two outlets onto public road, I'd hire 2 gate guards and make them lift the gate manually and salute me every time I came or went. I'd get them uniforms and everything.

5 years ago

Report

EMR

A near miss is a hit.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

livefoniks

lol, HOAs.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

LogicMan

Close one of the entrances permanently. Just make sure Fire and Rescue knows and can get in easily.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

cabmando

sounds like the entrance to Alvamar off 15th St, already looks like an obstacle course

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

RoeDapple

Move.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

DennisReynolds

Sometimes I feel like taking my 9 iron to the cars that drive through the alvamar parking lot at high speed.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

GUMnNUTS

First world problems.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

jaywalker

Unusually grumpy responses.

Take away the desire to use that road or drive fast; speed bumps or dips would work.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

MarcoPogo

"Unusually grumpy responses."

Wrong.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

kusp8

This!!

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

mdlund0

That's probably not wise... or legal. Oh, wait... that's definitely not wise and absolutely not legal.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Tara Painter

I live next to the highway, and sometimes you just have to deal with it, not everything is perfect, I have thefts all the time, but you don't see me complaining. You need to walk go to the track, the road is not that busy as it is in town, your complaing about 45 MPH! I would see whinning if there were going 60+ but it sounds like your like one of those old ladys where know one can step in your yard. You have to adjust to it like everyone else does when things change.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Jean Robart

caton---you might want
to use a dictionary before posting. Your spelling detracts from whatever it is that you are trying to say.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

parrothead8

Duh, whinning!

5 years ago

Report

Tara Painter

nowhere on here do I have to have perfect spelling of any kind. I think I do better at caring for my kids then any of you do, I wasn't born with a silver spoon in my mouth, some of us had to raise ourselves. If your going to make a comment stick to the topic being said on how other peoples grammer is!

5 years ago

Report

Know1StepsInMyYard

By everyone's logic, it would be fine if a child is hit and killed due to reckless driving, as long as it's on a privately owned road. Cool!

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

tolawdjk

No, it would not be "fine". I would think, however, that the parents of said child would have a strog case against the HOA for failure to adequately control their private road.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

parrothead8

Whose logic indicated that? I didn't see any statements before yours that seemed to disregard anybody's personal safety.

5 years ago

Report

Liberty275

Yes, the law can come out and prosecute a crime on private property with a warrant. I'm not sure they will be able to get a warrant to catch "reckless drivers". That is already too much a judgement call.

As for those of you who would say "my property, no warrant needed", what are you going to do when they catch your kid driving on your property without a license and you are in the seat beside them telling them how to use the clutch? You can't pay the law to prosecute some crimes or criminals and not others.

5 years ago

Report

Flap Doodle

Save the whales instead!

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

alittlecurious

Those are common problems on private roads... buyer beware!

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

kernal

Maybe the HOA should post a sign along the lines of "Private Property, Residents Only". That would keep most people out without having to put up gates, but gates are what many HOAs do in other states. You can get gates that open with a remote from your car. A drawback is when people take their remotes out of their cars and forget them.

I don't know how you're going to prove trespassing, unless residents are going to take turns sitting by the entrance with video cams to get shots of the drivers faces and tags.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Know1StepsInMyYard

If no (or know) one has figured it out by now, it's 15th and Crossgate. There are signs, and traffic calming devices. Since it's shared with the golf course, gates are not an option, unless everyone who ever wants to go the the driving range gets a remote.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Matthew Herbert

Having just finished up doing some work over on 15th & Crossgate (the Alvamar entrance off 15th) I'm imagining this is the exact road people are referencing. I will concur that it was indeed a race track for all those who flew down it. This is a death trap for pedestrians. Lock your kids inside, people racing off to their tee time will kill us all.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Know1StepsInMyYard

90% of the traffic on that road is not from the golf course, it's everyone cutting through the parking lot.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

gccs14r

It won't do any good to put up gates if it's the neighborhood residents who are speeding. Maybe the HOA should hire private security to enforce the speed limit. (You *do* have speed limit signs up, don't you? Or do they detract from the sterile aesthetics of suburbia?)

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

ElGonzo

Cheap HOA, poor design that allows easy drive through, no sidewalks, no bumps, and no signs. Raise your HOA fees and pay for the measures needed. It's private property your HOA can post the signs (hint: they won't work).

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

DillonBarnes

Make that parking lot prohibitively difficult to pass through. Could mean just reorganizing the parking lot in some way, or adding a gate somewhere. Make people who are coming into the parking lot stop at a gate to justify their crossing, give residents and club members a window sticker to pass through quickly.

If you're going to live on private property and allow the HOA to run the show, don't go looking to the city when you have a problem like that.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

PhilChiles

How about this: anyone who speeds is forced to attend a HOA meeting.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Katara

That falls under cruel and unusual punishment.

5 years ago

Report

Clovis Sangrail

Help me get this straight -- Crossgate running south from 15th (a.k.a. Bob Billings Pkwy) is a private road running from 15th to the Alvamar parking lot. Most of it along this length borders golf course, but there are half a dozen houses near 15th, the owner of one of which is most likely the question asker.

Or is this the portion of Crossgate that runs south from Alvamar to Clinton Parkway?

Is Crossgate a private road all the way from 15th to Clinton Pkwy? It does look like a nice way to get from 15th to Clinton Pkwy without having to go to Kasold or all the way out to Wakarusa.

Inquiring minds looking for a place to set up the after hours Lawrence Gran Prix want to know.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

local_support

Sounds like a great shortcut, I can't wait to use it.

*revs engine*

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

valgrlku

On a side note: I am unfamiliar with said "private streets" within city limits, even if the neighborhood has an HOA. Is this distinctive to Lawrence? How would one find out if said street is "private," before moving to that area? I find this bizarre, to say the least...

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

alittlecurious

Finding out is simple... 1) look at the subdivision plat for the location in question; 2) visit the city/county offices to look at the GIS; and 3) look to see if the street name sign is brown with white letters (that means its "private" in Lawrence).

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

ohjayhawk

Private streets are typically streets that are built and maintained solely by the property owner(s), on their own property, with no funds from the city.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

kernal

valgriku, an example of private streets not owned by the city would be the streets in Meadowbrook, the large apartment complex on the west side of Bob Billings Pkwy at Crestline Drive. Crestline Drive is a city owned street which divides the grounds. The streets on the grounds of Meadowbrook are not owned by the city, but by the corporate owner of Meadowbrook. The owner is responsible for the maintenance of those streets and snow and ice removal when needed. I think they also have speed limit signs posted, but not 100% sure.

Most HOAs that are gated communities own the streets on their grounds and those streets are designed so there is no through traffic to public access roads other than egress and ingress. HOAs which have streets that do have through traffic aren't gated and generally don't own their streets.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Matthew Herbert

I believe the following to be true: if the street sign is brown instead of green, it's private. For instance, at 31st and Kasold "Havrone Way" is actually a private drive for the Pear Tree Cottages HOA.

5 years ago

Report

jonas_opines

Is there anything left in you but troll, now? Sad.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

jonas_opines

Perhaps, but you might consider the alternative that when someone makes a legitimate claim that the actions of other people make them feel unsafe for themselves, their children, and their neighbors, and are unsure of how to address this concern, the response of: "deal with it, whiner!" and "idiotic question!" makes you sound like a coarse fool.

But, admittedly, that would require thought and introspection, two things you appear to do less and less of as the years on this forum go by.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

booyalab

This is truly a dumb question. Why would you even pay to live in a community with a private road that didn't have a gate or some other way of controlling traffic?

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

kansanbygrace

If the neighborhood and street are not in the city, they are still in the county. That's the Sheriff's department. They may have suggestions.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

kernal

Nope. It's not a public road.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

Joe Berns

...yet anyone can drive on it. Sounds public to me...

5 years ago

Report

kansanbygrace

Well Kernal, I never knew the Sheriff's authority was limited to traffic, nor their jurisdiction to public streets.
You think they have no authority there because it's "private", and couldn't investigate trespassing or burglary?
That's why I said "they may have suggestions."

5 years ago

Report

kernal

The subject is traffic control on a private road not owned by the city, not burglaries and trespassing. The sheriff's department also has no jurisdiction regarding the traffic problem. Just because the public uses the street does not make it a publicly owned street. The only other solution is to let the city own the street, since it seems it's not benefiting the HOA as a private street.

I can't imagine what other suggestions the sheriff's department would have than what the commenters have already listed. Will be interesting to see if they come up with anything, if the writer contacts them.

5 years ago

Report

irvan moore

does the city plow this street when it snows

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

asixbury

The short area that is private on Crossgate already has speed-controlling devices built (those half circles on either side of the drive). On that part of the road, you cannot really speed since you have to go around the obstacles mentioned above. The problem must be with the traffic going through the golf course parking lot. Seems like the best answer for the residents is for the HOA to build sidewalks and more speed humps.

I am guilty of using that shortcut sometimes. I live directly on the south side of the golf course and I work not far from the north side (less than a mile straight down Monterrey Way). It takes a lot less time, and is much more logical, for me to drive straight to my destination instead of back tracking to Clinton, then down to Kasold or Wakarusa, then over again to Monterrey. Bad placement of a "private" road.

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

1julie1

I don't use this shortcut because I don't go to the golf course. I do sympathize with the HOA which must pay for the maintenance of the street which is clearly being used as a faster route to Alvamar via the north side.

Why don't they just close the street at the end of the houses and town homes (wherever the Alvamar part of the road picks up inside the golf course)?

If someone wants to get to Alvamar they can come in through the public part of Crossgate off of Clinton Parkway.

The only reason I can see that the homeowners want to keep it open past their ending point is if they want to have access to Alvamar that way.

If Alvamar wants to keep it open as an access route for their patrons then they should fund the maintenance of the street and contribute to more traffic calming devices (maybe they do already - does anyone know one way or another?).

5 years, 1 month ago

Report

gccs14r

Ever heard of a Billings Snowflake? Take two 20d nails, file the heads off, bend them approximately 109°, weld them to each other perpendicularly, and paint the assembly white. In the case of the actual Billings Snowflake, IMS they were used during a refinery strike in Billings back around 1980. Striking workers made a bunch of these and tossed them into a snowy underpass to prevent scabs from driving product out of the refinery.

5 years ago

Report

chargeit

Good thing most on that road are postmenopausal. Nothing has really changed in 20 years but recently a school kid lost control of the vehicle (probably due to the islands) which probably sparked this "question". I have driven down the road before and been stared down by a resident that was standing far into the street almost daring. Lets face it, they are retired and dont have anything to do but complain.

5 years ago

Report

jonas_opines

William Wallace approves.
/mines, yes, I know

5 years ago

Report

kansanbygrace

Caltrops!

5 years ago

Report

Biker

You really have limited options. Either the HOA gets involved and identifies this a problem for which you they allocate resources or you ignore the problem. If neither of these seem likely, the next best solution is to move. I lived in an HOA for years learned this the hard way. Ultimately, I ended up moving out in the country where I didn't have these sorts of problems and my neighbors are more respectful. Good Luck.

5 years ago

Report

FlintHawk

Whoa. I don't have a pup in this fight, but I'm occasionally prompted to stand up for the underdog.
• I'm under the impression that the golf course used to be private, part of the "planned community." At that time, speeding and reckless driving presumably would not have been an issue, since only residents and their guests would have used the golf course/club. Has it occurred to any of you bashers that the questioner bought the home at that time and therefore could not have anticipated that the private drive would be used by the public?
• Secondly, if the residents along that stretch are retirees, does it occur to you that it may not be feasible for them to pick up and move to the country or elsewhere in Lawrence? It seems to me a paid-off mortgage is a powerful incentive to stay put, and relocating at 70+-years might seem to be a horrible solution. Just sayin' . . .

5 years ago

Report

jonas_opines

"Has it occurred to any of you bashers"

Of course not. Subject clarification unnecessary.

5 years ago

Report

Full LJWorld.com site